The Pros and Cons of Healthcare Chatbots

It is inferred that changes in the guardians’ vaccine confidence and acceptance will affect those of unvaccinated seniors, as family support is one of the most influential factors in senior vaccine hesitancy in this region32,33,34. However, this proxy approach might not directly reflect the changes in unvaccinated seniors’ vaccine confidence and acceptance. Further studies could advance the generalizability of chatbot interventions to target seniors, instead of their guardians, directly, and also investigate whether improve confidence in vaccine effectiveness could be translated into vaccination actions. Finally, our study focused on vaccine confidence and acceptance among numerous other factors that could drive vaccine hesitancy and deter children and seniors’ COVID-19 vaccine uptake. While vaccine confidence and acceptance are important attributes of vaccine uptake, our findings are not to be interpreted as the sole indicator of vaccination behaviours. Chatbots are conversational agents that act to replicate human interaction through text, speech, and visual forms of communication20,21.

• Slightly fewer (33%) think it would lead to worse outcomes and 27% think it would not have much effect.
• There are longstanding efforts by the federal government and across the health and medical care sectors to address racial and ethnic inequities in access to care and in health outcomes.
• The tool currently codes approximately half of the organization’s pathology cases, but the health system aims to increase this volume to 70 percent over the next year.
• In 2021, scientists criticized the application for failing to include darker skin tones when training the algorithm, making its results questionable for people with darker skin.

This convenience not only benefits patients but also reduces the administrative workload on healthcare providers. Seniors can also use AI chatbots to review medical coverage documents, health reports and benefits. It may cost more at the pharmacy than at the doctor’s office, depending on your coverage. Instead, you could ask a tool like DUOS and it will use the provided information to suggest the best options for you.

Authors and Affiliations

Artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots are established as tools for answering medical questions worldwide. You can foun additiona information about ai customer service and artificial intelligence and NLP. Healthcare trainees are increasingly using this cutting-edge technology, although its reliability and accuracy in the context of healthcare remain uncertain. Generative AI-based chatbots of various types have been deployed in virtual care, including for applications in patient triage, online symptom checking, patient education and mental healthcare. Future directions for this work involve the implementation of the proposed evaluation framework to conduct an extensive assessment of metrics using benchmarks and case studies.

Finally, human expertise and involvement are essential to ensure the appropriate and practical application of AI to meet clinical needs and the lack of this expertise could be a drawback for the practical application of AI. Several professional organizations have developed frameworks for addressing concerns unique to developing, reporting, and validating AI in medicine [69,70,71,72,73]. Instead of focusing on the clinical application of AI, these frameworks are more concerned with educating the technological creators of AI by providing instructions on encouraging transparency in the design and reporting of AI algorithms [69]. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is now developing guidelines on critically assessing real-world applications of AI in medicine while publishing a framework to guide the role of AI and ML in software as medical devices [74]. The European Commission has spearheaded a multidisciplinary effort to improve the credibility of AI [75], and the European Medicines Agency (EMA) has deemed the regulation of AI a strategic priority [76]. These legislative efforts are meant to shape the healthcare future to be better equipped to be a technology-driven sector.

You are unable to access ictworks.org

For example, a health system may deploy a chatbot to help filter patient phone calls, sifting out those that can be easily resolved by providing basic information, such as giving parking information to hospital visitors. Communication is a key aspect of patient experience and activation, and EHRs can help facilitate that communication by allowing patients and providers to send messages to one another anytime. However, overflowing inboxes can contribute to clinician burnout, and some queries can be difficult or time-consuming to address via EHR message. Medical research is a cornerstone of the healthcare industry, facilitating the development of game-changing treatments and therapies. But this research, particularly clinical trials, requires vast amounts of money, time and resources. In addition to helping monitor a patient’s status and detect potential health concerns earlier, AI technologies can also be deployed in clinical trials and other research.

Chuck thinks that admissions officers will learn to recognize the common prose of chatbot essays. Alex McFarland is an AI journalist and writer exploring the latest developments in artificial intelligence. “People see AI in binary ways – either it replaces a worker or you carry on as we are now,” said Lionel Tarassenko, professor of engineering science and president of Reuben College, Oxford. “It’s not that at all – it’s taking people who have low levels of experience and upskilling them to be at the same level as someone with great expertise. The Bristol Robotics Lab is developing a device for people with memory problems who have detectors that shut off the gas supply if a hob is left on, according to George MacGinnis, challenge director for healthy ageing at Innovate UK.

While there has been growing interest in chatbots across a range of public health areas19,27,41,42,43,48, very few studies have previously investigated the effectiveness of chatbots in promoting vaccine acceptance using RCTs43,49,50,51. For COVID-19 vaccination, our study lends weight to previous findings that interactive conversations between chatbots and users can contribute to increased vaccine confidence, as seen in the Thailand child group27,52. ‘Backfire effects’ are a controversial topic within the literature on digital health interventions—some research suggests that, in certain circumstances, pro-vaccine messaging delivered through social media can be counterproductive29. In the case of our study, it is unclear why certain groups should have seen adverse outcomes on certain variables. Conceivably, there may have been specific safety concerns or misinformation narratives that some had been less aware of prior to the study, and the process of engaging with the chatbot may have increased their familiarity with these topics or narratives.

Data management and extraction

AI-powered chatbots are sophisticated computer programs that utilize artificial intelligence, natural language processing (NLP), and machine learning algorithms to simulate human-like conversations with users. When my company works on any AI chatbot for a client who operates with sensitive data, we always include these practices in our development process. Experienced AI developers have already figured out how to mitigate the challenges of using AI in high-risk industries. Thanks to that, healthcare organizations can focus on improving their services with AI and improving patient care.

• These prompts come in the form of machine-readable inputs, such as text, images or videos.
• Generative AI captured public attention in November 2022 with the release of OpenAI’s ChatGPT, and since then, the tools have been increasingly deployed across industries.
• In an investigation of teenage smoking resistance, it was observed that negative prototype perceptions were more likely to profoundly influence behavioral decisions than positive perceptions (Piko et al., 2007).

Patients also can access health risk assessments, blood pressure tracking, prenatal testing, birth plans, and lactation support through the chatbot. Many healthcare experts feel that chatbots may help with the self-diagnosis of minor illnesses, but the technology is not advanced enough to replace visits with medical professionals. However, collaborative efforts on fitting these applications to more demanding scenarios are underway. Beginning with primary healthcare services, the chatbot industry could gain experience and help develop more reliable solutions.

Who do Americans feel comfortable talking to about their mental health?

Chat Generative Pre-trained Transformer (ChatGPT) is a powerful chatbot launched by open artificial intelligence (Open AI) (Roose, 2023) that has over 100 million users in merely 2 months, making it the fastest-growing consumer application (David, 2023). Our study population included guardians of those who were unvaccinated or delayed their COVID-19 vaccinations until the government vaccine mandates (Supplementary Method 2 and Supplementary Fig. 1). Children and seniors had the lowest vaccination coverages in all study regions despite their COVID-19 disease vulnerability. Since guardians can make direct or indirect vaccination decision on behalf of children and seniors, we tested the effectiveness of chatbot in increasing guardians’ vaccine confidence and acceptance for their dependent family members.

AI-powered chatbots are being implemented in various healthcare contexts, such as diet recommendations [95, 96], smoking cessation, and cognitive-behavioral therapy [97]. Patient education is integral to healthcare, as it enables individuals to understand their medical diagnosis, treatment options, and preventative measures [98]. Informed patients are more likely to adhere to their treatment regimens and achieve better health outcomes [99]. AI has the potential to play a significant role in patient education by providing personalized and interactive information and guidance to patients and their caregivers [100]. For example, in patients with prostate cancer, introducing a prostate cancer communication assistant (PROSCA) chatbot offered a clear to moderate increase in participants’ knowledge about prostate cancer [101]. Researchers found that ChatGPT, an AI Chatbot founded by OpenAI, can help patients with diabetes understand their diagnosis and treatment options, monitor their symptoms and adherence, provide feedback and encouragement, and answer their questions [102].

AI advancements in healthcare boost diagnostic accuracy, operational efficiency

Launched in 2016, Florence has made significant contributions by transforming various aspects of healthcare provision. Florence assists with medication reminders, tracks symptoms, and educates individuals about their health conditions. Based on artificial intelligence, this chatbot has helped countless patients improve their medication adherence and manage chronic diseases more efficiently, all while reducing the burden on healthcare providers. Trust is crucial in healthcare, making people wary of unfamiliar technologies that claim to offer medical assistance. Scepticism regarding the accuracy and effectiveness of healthcare chatbots may be a significant barrier to widespread adoption.

That presents a potential risk to patient confidentiality, according to Dr Caroline Green, an early career research fellow at the Institute for Ethics in AI at Oxford, who surveyed care organisations for the study. As AI continues to evolve and play a more prominent role in healthcare, the need for effective regulation and use becomes more critical. That’s why Mayo Clinic is a member of Health AI Partnership, which is focused on helping ChatGPT App healthcare organizations evaluate and implement AI effectively, equitably and safely. For example, AI has done a more accurate job than current pathology methods in predicting who will survive malignant mesothelioma, which is a type of cancer that impacts the internal organs. AI is used to identify colon polyps and has been shown to improve colonoscopy accuracy and diagnose colorectal cancer as accurately as skilled endoscopists can.

AI and other healthcare solutions cannot replace humans, but as these tools continue to advance, they are showing increasing promise to help augment the performance of the healthcare workforce. In healthcare, it’s often helpful to have another pair of hands when completing various care-related tasks, from gathering necessary supplies to performing complex surgeries. In the wake of ongoing healthcare workforce shortages, having enough staff to do the critical work of patient care is challenging. AI tools are also useful for streamlining labor-intensive tasks in the clinical setting, as evidenced by the rise of healthcare robotics. Some healthcare organizations have already seen success implementing AI-driven revenue cycle tools. These technologies are also useful because they can “learn” a patient’s baseline biometrics, which can help catch deviations from that baseline and adjust accordingly or alert the care team when a patient is at high risk for an adverse event.

It was conducted in three Asian regions, one being upper-middle-income and two being high-income. As this study was conducted during the aggressive implementation of containment interventions such as social distancing rules and mandatory vaccine pass schemes by the governments in our study sites, we employed the RCT design to evaluate the impact of the chatbot intervention. Chatbot development and evaluation were constantly updated and tailored to changing local epidemic situations and vaccine policies and programmes (e.g., approval of the 5–11 age group vaccinations)22 to disseminate accurate information. The questionnaires were standardised across countries and contexts to compare outcome variables of interest. The chatbots’ high practicality, flexibility (i.e., the ability to adapt to different settings, such as HPV vaccination campaigns), and scalability demonstrated promising evidence for future research and applications.

Firstly, the study focused on hypothetical scenarios and participants’ expected preferences, which may not fully reflect their actual choices and behaviors in real-life health situations. Future research should look to assess participant responses to actual interactions with medical chatbots, as well as investigating real-life choices around available consultation methods. It is also important to note that the study did not ask participants to consider practical factors that may influence their decision to choose a particular consultation method or the strength of their preference. According to the PWM, “reasoned action” and “social reaction” constitute the two pathways through which individuals process information (Gibbons et al., 1998).

This constant availability can be especially beneficial during moments of crisis, providing users with immediate assistance and resources. In the context of remote patient monitoring, AI-driven chatbots excel at processing and interpreting the wealth of benefits of chatbots in healthcare data garnered from wearable devices and smart home systems. Their applications span from predicting exacerbations in chronic conditions such as heart failure and diabetes to aiding in the early detection of infectious diseases like COVID-19 (10, 11).

The output from these chatbots is influenced by several factors, including the phrasing of questions, the user’s previous interactions with the AI, and ongoing optimisation processes conducted by the providers. In medical question-answering and increased reliability through clearer phrasing align with the test results published in ChatGPT-4’s technical report [26] However, the reliability among raters is still far from optimal or satisfying. Raters found it challenging to determine whether the AI’s altered wording still accurately represents the statements’ underlying causal and conditional relationships. This challenge for the raters may arise from the nature of the LLM function, which represents a statistical understanding of training data but lacks the conceptual understanding to genuinely comprehend real-world phenomena. Despite the general nature of the inquiries on the key messages of the ERC guideline chapters, the AI was able to maintain focus. The high conformity of 77% (ChatGPT-3.5) and 84% (ChatGPT-4) of the AI statements with the guidelines suggests a certain ability of the generative AIs to summarise and reproduce medical knowledge accurately.

Other experts are wary about patients using ChatGPT, with a March 2023 article indicating that ChatGPT can sometimes provide vague, unclear, or indirect information about common cancer myths. The UMSOM researchers crafted a set of 25 questions seeking advice about getting a breast cancer screening and asked ChatGPT each question three times to account for the way the chatbot varies ChatGPT its answers each time a query comes in. The projected benefits of using AI in clinical laboratories include but are not limited to, increased efficacy and precision. Automated techniques in blood cultures, susceptibility testing, and molecular platforms have become standard in numerous laboratories globally, contributing significantly to laboratory efficiency [21, 25].

Cross-sectional surveys based on respondents’ self-reports may have a common method bias (CMB) issue (Podsakoff et al., 2003). This study first employed Harman’s single-factor technique to examine possible CMB, and the results revealed that the single factor contributed 33.29% of the total variance and did not exceed the 50% threshold (Chang et al., 2020). Second, the potential marker method was used to evaluate CMB, utilizing age as the marker variable (Li et al., 2023); the results showed that the correlation coefficient between the marker variable and other variables in our model did not exceed 0.3 (Lindell and Whitney, 2001). Finally, the collinearity diagnostics results among the explanatory variables revealed that the variance inflation factor (VIF) was less than 3.3 (Kock, 2015). For example, surgeons can use robotic arms to conduct procedures, allowing for improved dexterity and range of motion.